Paul of Tarsus vs. Theodore of Tarsus

In the final battle of the First Round, Paul takes on Theodore in the epic Battle of Tarsus (you get extra Lent Madness points if you can find Tarsus on a map). The winner will do battle with Brigid of Kildare in the subsequent round.

Yesterday, in a hotly contested scrum between Margaret of Scotland and William Temple, Margaret ultimately emerged victorious 52% to 48% in heavy voting and commenting (119). Overall, it was a full day of Lent Madness news as the Supreme Executive Committee announced that they are threatening a lawsuit against some basketball tournament that uses "Madness" in the name. This led to an ensuing "controversy" over which virgin the state of Virginia was named after. Fortunately, this was all put into perspective on our Facebook fan page once a picture was posted of our two favorite voters, eight-year-0ld twins Hope and Skye of Burke, Virginia. Yes, that Virginia.

The Round of the Saintly Sixteen kicks off tomorrow with a fascinating match-up between two powerful and popular women, Joan of Arc and Mary Magdalene. Tickets are currently being scalped at astronomical prices.

Paul of Tarsus (5-67), the most influential Christian convert of the Early Church, is best known for his zeal in spreading Christianity and for writing more New Testament books than anyone else. His conversion story, from persecutor to disciple, involves an appearance of Christ so real that Paul insisted on calling himself an Apostle even though he had never met Jesus during Christ’s lifetime.

Paul was raised a pious Jew. His zeal for the Jewish faith is detailed in the Book of Acts where Paul condoned the stoning of Stephen, Christianity’s first martyr. Paul was then famously converted on the road to Damascus when he was blinded, knocked off his horse, and addressed by the voice of Christ. Following this conversion his name was changed from Saul to Paul. He then set out on full-time missionary activities, helping spread the Gospel to early Christian communities throughout the Mediterranean.

Paul’s journey included incarceration, which is where he wrote several famous letters to his followers, including Galatians and Philippians. Fourteen epistles in the New Testament are attributed to Paul.

Paul took three missionary journeys, the final one ended in Rome where he settled as a tent maker and Christian leader. Christian tradition says Paul was beheaded during the reign of Nero around the mid-60’s. He is often depicted in art with a bald head. He shares his feast day with St. Peter who was crucified upside down, also in Rome, at the same time.

Collect for Peter and Paul: Almighty God, whose blessed apostles Peter and Paul glorified you by their martyrdom: Grant that your Church, instructed by their teaching and example, and knit together in unity by your Spirit, may ever stand firm upon the one foundation, which is Jesus Christ our Lord; who lives and reigns with you, in the unity of the Holy Spirit, one God, now and for ever. Amen.

-- Chris Yaw

Theodore of Tarsus, also known as Theodore of Canterbury (602 - 690) was, according to the Venerable Bede, “the first archbishop [of Canterbury] whom all the English obeyed.” Tarsus was a city in Asia Minor (modern day Turkey), part of the Byzantine Empire, the same city that the Apostle Paul called home. At some point, Theodore moved to Constantinople and later to Rome to join a community of Eastern monks. At the age of sixty-six, he was appointed seventh Archbishop of Canterbury, a seat which had been vacant for four years.

Most of the information we know about Theodore comes from the aforementioned Bede, who reported that Theodore first of all had to grow out his hair for four months so he could switch from the Eastern to the Western tonsure. Soon after his consecration, Theodore traveled around England, appointing bishops (there were many vacancies due to the plague) and reorganizing dioceses to make them of manageable size for both pastoral care and administration. Upon his return to Canterbury he drew up a book of canon law to organize the Church in England, a diverse church of Roman, Celtic, and Anglo-Saxon Christians. Theodore, perhaps because he was a Greek who lived in many places himself and was an outsider, was able to bring all the parties together into one Church despite the ill feelings engendered from the Council of Whitby’s decision in 663 to favor Roman over Celtic practices in Britain.

Theodore also established the influential school at Canterbury modeled on the great school in Antioch where Theodore himself may well have studied. Latin and Greek, poetics, computistics (the calculation of the church calendar, which was a big issue in that time and place), astronomy, Biblical exegesis and church music were taught at the Canterbury school. The liturgical use of sacred music as taught at Canterbury (which included Roman chant) spread throughout England during Theodore’s archbishopric.

Theodore served for twenty-two years as Archbishop of Canterbury and died at the age of eighty-eight. He is venerated as a saint in both the Anglican (including The Episcopal Church) and Eastern Orthodox churches. His feast day is celebrated on September 19.

Collect for Theodore of Tarsus: Almighty God, who called your servant Theodore of Tarsus from Rome to the see of Canterbury, and gave him gifts of grace and wisdom to establish unity where there had been division, and order where there had been chaos: Create in thy Church, we pray, by the operation of the Holy Spirit, such godly union and concord that it may proclaim, both by word and example, the Gospel of the Prince of Peace; who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God, for ever and ever. Amen.

-- Penny Nash

Vote!

[poll id="8"]

Subscribe

* indicates required

Recent Posts

Archive

Archive

103 comments on “Paul of Tarsus vs. Theodore of Tarsus”

  1. Theo betook himself from the sunny Mediterranean to wet, chilly England, where he no doubt tromped around the muddy countryside on foot and lived in drippy thatched buildings. He lived to a ripe old age in spite of it all. He's got my vote

  2. Gee, I went away and had a real life for six hours and return to find Theo's still trailing miserably. He needs his own personal Diocese of Hawaii.

  3. The guy had a terrific conversion story, wrote a TON and died for the cause. Although I don't appreciate some of his ideas, I must go with Paul.

  4. Looks like Paul is going to trounce poor Teddy... but that will put him up against Emma of Hawaii, and we know how those Hawaiians rally to their girl's cause. So I'm not going to worry too much about this one, even though I voted for ol' Theo... because in the next round, Paul is gonna get his clock cleaned!

    1. Um...guys? You said this:
      "...The winner will do battle with Brigid of Kildare in the subsequent round.

      But in your calendar you've got the winner of this match going up against Emma.

      So who is it? Emma or Brigid?!?

  5. I was going to vote for Paul, because I'm going to be studying him this summer and have started reading this very promising looking book about him.

    But there was a lot in Theodore's story that attracted my attention. He travelled around England reorganizing dioceses to make them of manageable size for both pastoral care and administration? Would that someone would do that today!

    He set up a school based on the school at Antioch? He brought together Christians of different rites.. and is honored as a saint by both Anglicans and Eastern Orthodox?

    I've got to go with Theodore!

  6. There's no denying Paul is a Giant in the history of the church and everybody knows him. But my wife and I voted for Theodore because we feel that the lesser known saints deserve recognition. Sad to say, some Episcopal parishes don't observe ANY
    saints days . As a result, so many holy men and women are unknown to their sisters
    and brothers here on earth. Thank God for Lent Madness and its efforts to correct this.

  7. i learned where Tarsus was in my Church of Christ days.

    i also heard words that seemed to burn the air: "Saul, Saul, why persecutes thou me?" "Almost thou persuadest me to be a Christian." not said by Paul, but to him: compelling somehow, even if i can't agree with every verse of the letters.

  8. Theodore took Paul's teaching & ran with it. Along the way, he organized dioceses, staffed plague depleated churches, started schools and introduced new music in the English church. Too bad we don't have Theodore's writings! Nothing against Paul, though he could use a few extra commas & semi-collens.