Clare of Assisi vs. Scholastica

The war for Westminster’s door is officially closed! 🚪 Archbishop Janani Luwum marches on after defeating Wang Zhiming 58.1% to 41.9%, punching his ticket to the Saintly Sixteen! 🙌

But enough about the guys… today belongs to the sisters! 👑

It’s a holy sibling showdown as Clare of Assisi takes on Scholastica. Will Scholastica follow in the saintly footsteps of her brother Benedict and advance? Or will Clare keep the Franciscan magic alive and chase a Golden Halo like her pal Francis? ✨

Two holy women. One heavenly slot in the Saintly Sixteen.

Watch the video, read the blog, and cast your vote! 🗳️🔥

Clare of Assisi

When you think of saints from Assisi, Clare might not be the very first one who comes to mind, but she’s definitely the second. Hers is something of a riches-to-rags story. Clare was born to a wealthy count in Italy. Her devout mother sparked a keen religious interest in Clare and her two sisters from an early age…so much so that when her parents decided it was time for Clare to be married, she high-tailed it to Francis (as in Saint Francis of Assisi) and pleaded to be admitted to a holy order so she could devote herself entirely to worship and study of Jesus Christ.

Her deep commitment to emulating Christ (and to a lesser extent, Francis) fueled her journey from becoming a teenage nun to co-founding a religious order with Francis himself in 1212, called the Order of Poor Ladies. Later, they would become known as the Order of Saint Clare, now more commonly referred to as the “Poor Clares.” Unsurprisingly, given the name, the order adhered to a vow of strict poverty. So strict, in fact, that Pope Gregory IX nearly forbade them from continuing to follow it, for fear that it was detrimental to the sisters’ health. Even in this, Clare’s faith was unwavering. Her steadfastness convinced the Pope to let her have her way (as a reminder, “her way” was strict poverty). Though her faith made her a powerful force of nature, she was anything but power-hungry; she actively (though unsuccessfully) resisted becoming abbess of the religious order she co-founded, and wanted to be seen more as a servant to her fellow nuns than a master.

The miracle most commonly cited in any story of Clare’s life occurred in 1240, when Saracen armies attacked her convent. A frail Clare prayed over the Eucharist for protection. According to this legend, Clare then revealed the Holy Sacrament to the encroaching army, and they fled at the sight of it, as if blinded.

Another miraculous tale is that Clare, too ill to attend a Christmas mass, was granted a clear vision of the entire service as if she had been there in person. This story is so legendary that, over 700 years later (in 1958), it led to humble Clare being named the patron saint of television!

That said, maybe the most telling triumphs of Clare’s lifetime aren’t the ones that get labeled as “miracles.” Her spiritual influence was so mighty that not only did her two (biological) sisters follow her into the order, but after her father died, her mother joined as well. She is the first woman to write her own Rule for a monastery, in 1252. And just a day or two after learning that her Rule had been approved by the Vatican, Clare died, praising God for the life he had given her. She was canonized only two years after her death.

Marissa Flaxbart

Collect for Clare of Assisi

O God, whose blessed Son became poor that we through his poverty might be rich: Deliver us from an inordinate love of this world, that we, inspired by the devotion of your servant Clare, might serve you with singleness of heart, and attain to the riches of the age to come; through Jesus Christ our Lord, who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God, for ever and ever. Amen.

 

Scholastica

Scholastica was the founder of the Benedictine order of nuns and the sister of Benedict of Nursia. Born in 480 in Nursia, many traditions say that she was Benedict’s twin. She and Benedict were raised together until he went off to school in Rome.

Scholastica, on the other hand, became a consecrated virgin, and established a community with a handful of other dedicated women in Monte Cassino. Pope Gregory the Great records that she was dedicated to God from an early age, and most likely lived as a consecrated virgin in her parents’ house, then moved near her brother’s monastery when he founded it in Monte Cassino, beginning her own community of nuns.

According to the most famous legend, she and her brother would meet one day each year, to eat together and discuss scripture and spiritual matters. They had a house halfway between their monasteries reserved for this purpose. One day, as they were meeting, Benedict got up to go, but Scholastica requested that he stay the night to spend more time with her. He declined–and suddenly a massive thunderstorm erupted outside. Benedict panicked, but Scholastica calmly reported that since he hadn’t listened to her, she asked God, and God had–so he could leave if he wanted, but she imagined it would be pretty hard. Left without many options, Benedict elected to stay the night, chatting with his sister through the evening about the kingdom of heaven.

Scholastica died three days later in 543, and Benedict saw her soul ascending to heaven as a dove.

She is remembered today as the patron saint of Benedictine nuns, education, children with convulsive disorders, and as providing protection against thunderstorms.

Megan Castellan

Collect for Scholastica

Assist us, O God, to love one another as sisters and brothers, and to balance discipline with love and rules with compassion, according to the example shown by your servant Scholastica; for the sake of your Son Jesus Christ our Lord, to whom with you and the Holy Spirit be all honor and glory, now and for ever. Amen.

This poll is no longer accepting votes

VOTE
5680 votes
VoteResults

Subscribe

* indicates required

Recent Posts

Archive

Archive

53 comments on “Clare of Assisi vs. Scholastica”

  1. When a vow of poverty is so extreme it comes tot he notice of the Pope it must be very extreme. Reading stories like this I am reminded of the tradition that when we die, the one question God will ask of us is 'Did you enjoy my creation?' I vote for Scholastica, who enjoyed the thunderstorm and the gift it gave her of her brother's company.

    14
    1. I love that idea of Scholastica enjoying creation (the thunderstorm) to have more of her brother's company.
      I also enjoy the irony that Scholastica requester of thunderstorms is the saint for protection against them!

      3
  2. My mother's middle name was Clara (in Germany, then Clare when she came to the US) and I'm now retired from St. Francis' so I had to vote for Clare. We had a grand celebration when Francis won the Golden Halo.

    3
  3. Jesus was derided as "a glutton and a wine-bibber" by his enemies, although he was apparently just somebody who enjoyed a meal and a glass of wine with friends. He is not recorded as saying that we must starve ourselves in order to enter the kingdom of heaven. Clare's rule for her order must have been extrene indeed that it caused concern from the Pope. I voted for Scholastica, who enjoyed theological discussions with her brother.

    6
  4. Once again a shoddy biography prevents one candidate from even having a chance against the other, in this case it "poor" Scholastica. These have been by far the least balanced biography pairings we've had in years.
    And by the way, BRING BACK THE BOOKLETS!!!

  5. While I loved the stories of both women, I had to vote for St. Clare. We could probably benefit from the Florida Rainy Season under the care of Scholastica.

    PS - did not receive my email today. I forward it to other members of my parish so we participate together.

  6. Voted for Scholastica. Seems like a more "normal" sort of woman, and I loved the story of their brother/sister bond and her declaring the storm was God's way of making him longer for their annual visit. Also, sorry for those who liked her, but Clare - that fanatical type. And sort of arrogant, putting hersel fup against the Pope.

    2
  7. Two noble and deserving women; but I fell in love with Assisiwhen I visited and was able to celebrate Mass at St. Francis, so you know who got my vote.

    1
    1. Our rector and his wife just left for the big 800th celebration in Assisi.

      1
  8. Both orders began as cloistered and are still cloistered, if I understand rightly, and I find that troubling. I love San Damiano, in Assisi, the place of Clare's first nunnery, and one of the early abandoned chapels Francis literally repaired when the Jesus spoke to him and said "rebuild my house." The original Byzantine crucifix, praying before which Francis heard Jesus's voice, is now in the chapel of Assisi's Order of Saint Clare, and I spent a moving evening there, at a service, praying before that very same cross. Yet, even there, I found it troubling that they women were almost not to be seen. So many women have been locked away for all kinds of purposes. I know it would have been likely impossible for Clare to have moved freely outside the world, as Francis did. But I wish that were not so.

    2
  9. I appreciate the work of Clare and her sisters on behalf of the poor. Giving up a comfortable life for full poverty takes a true dedication to God. I decided on Scholastica because I also appreciate the dedication to learning and prayer she displayed very early in life, and then followed her brother into founding a convent and developing a Rule for her sisters to follow. That was no mean feat in the world in which she lived. Her brother, Benedict, seems to have loved her for these traits and discipline too.

  10. At the height of the CoViD pandemic, Holy Clare (patroness of videoconferencing) provided us a safe passage to collective worship. I, having been rendered immunocompromised not long afterwards by modes of medical treatment, continued in my gratitude for Clare's example and patronage to the present moment, and the holy fellowship of her blessed company renders my vote a no-brainer!

    1
  11. The videos show trading cards- maybe mock ones. Will real ones be available? I miss those.