Welcome to the Faithful Four, friends. After weeks of learning and voting and occasionally squabbling (in a holy, churchy kind of way) we have whittled the field down to four spiritual heavyweights: Mary Magdalene, Margaret of Scotland, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, and Emma of Hawaii. Collectively, it's a fascinating group of four heroes of the faith stretching from Biblical times to the 20th century.
As we like to tell our five-year-olds when they join their first soccer team (that's football for our friends across the pond), "there are no losers, everybody's a winner." Of course we're lying. Thus, while we can sing the praises of these saints, only one Golden Halo will be awarded.
Today Mary Magdalene (Meredith Gould) takes on Margaret of Scotland (Penny Nash); tomorrow Dietrich Bonhoeffer (Neil Alan Willard) battles Emma of Hawaii (Heidi Shott); and on Spy Wednesday the championship round will take place. In this round, we let our four remaining Celebrity Bloggers loose as they answer the question "Why should Saint XX win the Golden Halo?" In other words, they've been charged with letting us know why their particular saint is so awesome. And, in a nod to the fact that the SEC is responsive to the cries of (some of) the masses, we are including a few works of saintly art.
To make it to the Faithful Four, Mary Magdalene dispatched John Huss, Joan of Arc, and Evelyn Underhill with relative ease. Margaret of Scotland bested William Temple and John Cassian before squeaking by Enmegahbowh. See the updated bracket and then please vote just once.
What calls any of us to embrace a particular saint? Our saints are extraordinary models of Christian faith and fidelity. Throughout history, all have endured conditions and situations that, despite our best imaginations, we cannot fully comprehend.
These women and men of God are spiritual Sherpas, guiding us along the path; welcoming us back when we wonder and wander away. What makes Mary Magdalene first among equals is simply this:
“When Jesus rose early on the first day of the week, he appeared first to Mary Magdalene…” (Mark 16:9).
Jesus is indisputably the Christ, and entrusts Mary Magdalene with the near-thankless task of reporting his Resurrection from the dead. The disciples do not immediately believe her story of death defeated. Gospel stories about their resistance to hearing this liberating truth from a woman foreshadows a woeful and ongoing history of truth denied and evangelists mocked. (I sometimes find myself asking what has changed.)
While I have a (short) list of holy women and men who help sustain my faith, Mary Magdalene, Apostle to the Apostles, is my radical go-to saint. Contemplating her love and loyalty to Christ Jesus keeps my heart from breaking whenever I focus too long on wreckage wrought in the name of religion. For all this and more, she’s already wearing a golden halo.
Click here to see my Mary Magdalene board on Pinterest.
Why should Margaret of Scotland win the Golden Halo? Because she was an awesome, saintly saint! Oh, yeah? you may ask...well, read on.
Margaret was intelligent, beautiful and devout, and she walked the walk of Christian service. After her rescue from shipwreck in Scotland, she gave up her plan of withdrawing into a nunnery and married a rough Scottish king and changed the ethos in the court and castle. Eventually the king himself was converted to the faith, thanks not only to her fervent daily prayers but also her daily charitable works.
She rose at midnight to pray (remember how her husband followed her into a cave, thinking she met with an enemy, only to find her in earnest prayer for him?) and in the mornings refused to eat anything herself until she had fed from her own hand nine orphans and given bread and alms to all the needy people who crowded into the great hall. She and King Malcolm washed the feet of beggars who came to them for assistance, even when it wasn’t Maundy Thursday.
Inspired by the Bible, during Advent and Lent, she hosted 300 non-royal people in the castle for banquets where she and Malcolm waited the tables, and she established not only several monasteries (including rebuilding Iona) and churches (for which she sewed fine vestments herself) but also had hostels constructed for the poor.
Further, Margaret had shelters built for travelers and paid the ransom to set free English captives. And she created a free ferry system across the Firth of Forth to convey pilgrims to the shrine of Saint Andrew. I just love ferries, don’t you? Gliding across the water in the brisk salt air, wind in my hair, gulls wheeling and crying overhead, plumes of sea spray arching over the bow as the boat cuts through the waves...What? Oh. Sorry.
Margaret was a queen and wealthy, but she considered herself only a steward of that wealth. She used her power, influence, and resources to assist the poor and the hungry, orphans and pilgrims, prisoners and captives, as well as to build hostels, churches and abbeys. Instead of withdrawing from the world, she lived a disciplined life of labora et ora, work and prayer, in the world.
Margaret was not born at a time when she could touch Christ in person, but she strove to seek and serve Christ in everyone that she met in her own time and place. Plus she established the Queen’s Ferry and was awesome. She set an example for all of us to follow. And so, she deserves your vote for the Golden Halo!
-- Penny Nash
Vote!
[poll id="32"]
91 comments on “Mary Magdalene vs. Margaret of Scotland”
Re: write-ups. Speaking as a writer among these writers, I feel privileged to be writing with and for this group!
As do I!
<3 you, Penny.
But Emma may, and I don't want that!
Scottish heritage and Celtic pride must take a back seat to the woman who was there, indisputably there, for it all. Both are high in my admiration, but (sorry, Penny) Mary Magdalene gets my vote, always!
Margaret wasn's a Scot or Celt. She was a Saxon who hated the Gaelic language and the Celtic Church and did her best to eradicate both. (Sorry to be a broken record on this subject!). As a descendant of Gaelic Highlanders, I can't vote for her. No contest here between the queen of mean and Mary Mags,
Excellent write ups. Hard decision. I enjoyed the art. Can't help but admire Margaret. Voting for Mary.
Amen again, Dr. Primrose. On the other hand, the reproduction of Margaret's chapel at St. Margaret's in Palm Desert, CA, is well worth visiting.
I have often wondered if Mary ever said to herself, "Why me"? Jesus could have appeared to Peter who denied him thrice or to Thomas who needed more proof or to Joseph who arranged for the tomb in the first place--but Mary?--What an extraordinary thing for Jesus to do, but then he never ceased to surprise us
Alec, the women traditionally had mortuary duty, or so I've been told. Scholars, any opinion?
We, in the 21st century, might write a play. Such as: MM goes introspective; Pete & Tom grouse about being johnny-come-lately (s); Joe A. is stunned when he Finally gets the news. (Film at 11.)
Okay, I'm being silly. (Compare/contrast the two centuries.)
The truth is, as you said, Jesus is a surprise. Still. An Awesome surprise.
If you had ever told me I would find myself voting against Margaret of Scotland.....This is madness!
Meredith, interesting quote from my sociologist son this morning from Max Weber about how not everyone has access to the same opportunities. You know, life chances.
I keep going back and forth on this one. Have no idea how I will end up voting.
Mary Mag is important to the Church. Being able to stand before a king with enough fortitude and have the egg turn red is amazing. However, she was with Jesus. Not that the cost of discipleship is ever cheap, but she had Jesus personally to teach her. She had sight, as well as faith.
The rest of us have only faith to go on. Queen Margaret went with that faith and changed a people.
Nicely thought, Bob...
Thanks.
Even a blind squirrel gets an acorn of a thought occasionally.
Here's a nice video of the Easter Sequence (in Latin, though!): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XxgDAtLcIyg
You get to see a San Marco mosaic, too - and I think that's Mary Mags right there in front....
After dissing the Celts through the first rounds I am going for Margaret. She really had to walk the walk (in bluidy Scotland, no less)....and I'm thinking an Emma / Margaret showdown would be Super Cool. So up the Scots!
The Apostle to the Apostles gets my vote in this round.
It's sad that your book of saintly devotions is only available as an ebook. I've tried but I can't pray with a screen. Guess I am too old to learn new tricks. Let me know if you ever publish it as a real book.
After General Convention meets this summer, we are likely to publish a paper book, based on the current calendar of the Episcopal Church. We didn't want to print this version and have it be out of date.
Speaking of e-publishing, is there a way to get the LM "game" for people who don't/won't use computers? I was explaining LM to the wife of our rector emeritus. She was amused by the concept of LM; I wished I had something concrete to show her. (Also, we have a neighbor w/o computer by choice. Perhaps others in the same boat.)
I have to vote for my beloved companion patroness!
Amen yet again Dr. Primrose. My ancestors had their lands in Scotland seized by one of Margaret's sons and given to the church because they refused to accept the church that Margaret and her husband created. To honor the memory of my family and the religious persecution that they suffered I will give my vote to Mary.
I couldn't have said it better:
"While I have a (short) list of holy women and men who help sustain my faith, Mary Magdalene, Apostle to the Apostles, is my radical go-to saint. Contemplating her love and loyalty to Christ Jesus keeps my heart from breaking whenever I focus too long on wreckage wrought in the name of religion. For all this and more, she’s already wearing a golden halo."
Go Mary and claim your rightful place at the top.
Mary is the heroine of heroines as well as Apostle to the Apostles.
My favorite window in St. John's (in Albuquerque) is "The Three Marys." Below is something, not from the hymnal, but expresses my feelings quite well.
The Ballad of Mary Magdalen
from Blue Divide
My name is Mary Magdalen
I come from Palestine
Please excuse these rags Im in
But Ive fallen on hard times
But long ago I had my work
When I was in my prime
But I gave it up, and all for love
It was his career or mine
Jesus loved me
This I know
But why on earth
Did I ever let him go
He was always faithful
He was always kind
But he walked off
With this heart of mine
A love like this will come but once
This I do believe
And Ill not see his like again
As I live and breath
And Im sorry if I might offend
But I will never see
How the tenderness I shared with him
Became a heresy
Jesus loved me
This I know
But why on earth
Did I ever let him go
He was always faithful
He was always kind
But he walked off
With this heart of mine
But I remember nights we spent
Whispering our creed
Our rituals, our sacraments
The stars our canopy
There beneath an olive tree
Wed offer up our plea
Gods creation innocent
His arms surrounding me
Jesus loves me
This I know
But why on earth
Did he ever have to go
He was always faithful
He was always kind
But he walked off
With this heart of mine
© 2012 Richard Shindell
Love that!
I'm amazed so many are conflicted on this one. I'm one of those ScotIrish Celts who see all too clearly the political difficulties of voting for Margaret. And even so, come on....the Magdalen? There's no contest here, WWJD? Ha! Like most men who love the one they are with, I feel certain he'd vote for His very own Mary.
Meredith: I loved your pinterest page. The picture you like with the haunting eyes is painted by an artit named Richard Stodart. On google it said it is for sale.
Which one with the haunting eyes -- I think there are a couple. Would you post a comment there so I can fix the description? BTW, I futz around with Pinterest to relax and soak in beauty at the end of a day with words.
I wonder what the people in Scotland today think of Margaret. Saint? Sinner?
Yawn? (tut-tut).
Though I have no axe to grind against Margaret (the ancestors apparently left their axes in the Old Country), I'm sort of awe struck by Mary being at the tomb. Dumbfounded, actually. I'm voting for amazement. In amazement. The Magdalene.
Decisions, decisions, decisions. I believe this is the hardest vote of all. Can I split my vote? Mary Magdalene has to get my vote because of her role in the early church and as the Apostle to the Apostles. Sorry, Margaret.
I love Mary Magdalene, but this is the Final Faith-full Four. How much harder it is to be faithful when you are not basking in the glow of the Source? Mary was right there with our Lord. Margaret practiced her faith 1000 years later. I certainly think Margaret's faith is nothing to yawn about. I really find the critical nature of some people's comments so un-Christ like. All the saints and their devotees are worthy of our respect. Give respectful reasons for your vote but do not criticize the other saint or his or her fans.
Patsy, I'm afraid I wasn't very clear in my previous post. Since I am in the U.S. and not in Scotland, I am curious about how Queen Margaret is percieved in Scotland in our century. We have read much about Margaret's accomplishment during her lifetime. Some people reading LM expressed unhappiness or dismay over Queen Margaret's treatment of the Celts. So, I am curious to know what the Scots think today. Is she thought of as a saint or a sinner? Or, worse yet, are people dismissive of her? Do the Scots today remember her for her organization and her charity to orphans or for crushing the Celt culture?
In my opinion, Queen Margaret's Christ-light still shines brightly.
A tough vote for Hope and Skye tonight. It was tough to vote against the saintly lade who turned eggs from white to red. What swayed them to go for Mary Magdalene was that she close to Jesus ... and they were also swayed by all of the lovely pictures of her on the pinterest site!
Oh, Jesus could really lay it on when he wanted to. All of Matthew 23 is pretty much a long-winded rant against the scribes and the Pharisees. A couple of highlights:
"For you are like whitewashed tombs, which on the outside look beautiful, but inside they are full of the bones of the dead and of all kinds of filth."
"You snakes, you brood of vipers! How can you escape being sentenced to hell?"
[...] celebrity blogger Meredith Gould shared her Pinterest board of images of Mary Magdalene in her writeup (aka lobbying) for today’s match. Thanks, Meredith – these are [...]
Yikes, Dr. P. tough act to follow...
"For it was Mary, Mary... Plain as any name can be", but consider this short list of her monikers...Apostle of the Apostles, sinful woman , Myrrhbearer, Lady Bug, Beloved Disciple, Christ Loved, Equal of the Apostles< Holy Grail?, The Magnificent, The Penitent...and Begley's vote receiver.
Gotta go with the original "Bad Girl of The Bible." I love Mary Magdelene. She had the love for Jesus that most of us can only dream of achieving in our lifetime.
Thanks for the wonderful lessons. I didn't know anything about Margaret before this and she is a fascinating and inspirational woman. Hard to choose between the two, and I can't even begin to imagine that moment when Jesus said "Mary" and she knew it was him.
Margret is a wonderful example of the Christian life, but my vote is for Mary. Hers was a life transformed both by the living Christ and by the risen Lord.